Player Empowerment in Breath of the Wild

The most refreshing thing about The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild is that it trusts the player.

As games grew into the mainstream, they began to make more concessions for accessibility. This isn’t inherently a bad thing. More people playing games is almost always a good thing. However, games shouldn’t make concessions that compromise what they’re about. Anyone can pick up Devil May Cry. Anyone can beat it if they put the effort in. But Devil May Cry doesn’t compromise. When it did, it didn’t go over well.

More than anything else, Breath of the Wild is a game about exploration, so it’s refreshing that Breath of the Wild doesn’t make unnecessary compromises to sacrifice that focus. In fact, the entire game is structured from the ground up in order to better facilitate exploration in the truest sense.

Exploration in many contemporary roleplaying and adventure games is a misnomer. Minimaps are flooded with icons and GPS-esque paths to follow. More egregious games like The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim have a compass attached to the screen that points the player in the direction of their targeted quest. The result is that the player no longer explores the world and instead follow pre-selected markers.

Compare the vanilla World of Warcraft leveling experience to post-Cataclysm. A quest helper system was not integrated into the basic experience. Quests were written to mention landmarks and other aspects of the terrain to help guide the player to their location. There were exceptions among the thousands of quests, like Mankrik’s wife, but even that gave the player a clue to follow – close to the Gold Road in the Barrens.

Quests in World of Warcraft now don’t have to be well written. The text no longer has to carry the weight of the quest. Instead, waypoint markers and quest areas guide the player from objective to objective. This same same development is apparent in the transition from The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind to the current state of the franchise in Skyrim. Morrowind communicated clues and a written journal so players could investigate and piece together their quests.

The advantage of this system is that it allows players a sense of satisfaction as they explore and discover, while the contemporary system directly tells the player what to do with no opportunity for misinterpretation. The former makes players feel good because they feel smart. They’re in charge of their own adventure. Every quest contains at least a marginal sense of mystery. It also widens the opportunity for emergent adventures. Without a blinking GPS signal urging them along, the player is much more likely explore off their original path.

A slower pace is integral to exploration in games. A checklist of waypoints is equivalent to a grocery list: you know that the items exist and where to find them. The goal becomes the focus. Breath of the Wild reminds players that adventuring is about the journey.
From the ground up, Breath of the Wild focuses on empowering the player. All the tools are available for the player to adventure on their own. While waypoints are available, the game still plays properly even when turned off in favor of the Pro HUD.

Proper world building is key. The post-calamity Hyrule is beyond vast, but difficult to get lost in. Several landmarks are visible at almost any point in the world. Global landmarks, like Hyrule Castle, Death Mountain, the Dueling Peaks, help orient the player within the larger world map. At least one of those landmarks are visible from almost any vantage point in the world.

1488476119525-nintendoswitch_tlozbreathofthewild_presentation2017_scrn09_png_jpgcopy
At the bottom of cliffs at the end of Hyrule, Death Mountain is still visible.

Each region has distinct details for the same reason. The spires of Rito Village are a great centerpiece between the Hebra Mountains and Hyrule Ridge. The Akkala Highlands have several coastal landmarks to mark the player’s latitude in one of the game’s most vertically stretched zones.

Stables and towers help with this too. Both are as noticeable within their own regions as other landmarks but towers are usually also visible from other areas of the map. Players can use them as a guide in their adventures or scale them for a better vantage point. Unlike Ubisoft-inspired adventure games, the towers in Breath of the Wild don’t clutter the minimap with icons. Instead, the player can use the high ground to examine areas of interest and mark their own interests to explore later.

Quests are equally refreshing. Even when tracked in the journal, the quest’s target isn’t specifically marked on the map. At best, the general area is marked. Text and dialogue are necessary to understand and complete the tasks. Quests are made up of riddles, puzzles and rumors that must be pieced together. More importantly, the game trusts them to do so.

Some of the best sidequests in the game are related to Kass, a wandering Rito bard with possibly the best music in the game. Kass appears all across Hyrule, his location betrayed by the telltale tones of his accordion. Once found, he gives the player a riddle in song. The solutions involve the location surrounding Kass, some answer to unearth in order to reveal a shrine. Some of these get clever, but they always guide the player to pay better attention to the environment they’re exploring.

Concessions for less skilled players still exist, in case they prefer a minimap and more displayed information or are unable to complete the game without them. The Sheikah Sensor is almost blatant. It vibrates whenever the player is near a shrine or an item they chose to track. Luckily, these systems can be turned off, although they are on by default.

The fact that the game still functions without those stacked systems demonstrates Breath of the Wild’s mastery. The game begs to be played with the Pro HUD, almost like it was created with the Pro HUD in mind before the minimap, Sheikah Sensor and noise display were added on later.

Not only does Breath of the Wild trust the player to take charge of their own adventure, it is designed to let them. It makes the player want to. Contemporary tools that players might be accustomed to from other games are still present for those that wish to use them but they aren’t necessary. It demonstrates that the best of both worlds is possible. Players can be trusted and games can take advantage of that. Games can be vast and open, their eventual borders so far beyond the imagination that their existence isn’t even considered when the world first presents itself, ready to be explored. It takes confidence. It takes courage. Breath of the Wild brims with both.

 

 

Missed Potential: Mass Effect 2

MAJOR SPOILERS FOR THE MASS EFFECT FRANCHISE BELOW, SPECIFICALLY MASS EFFECT 1, 2 AND 3. 

In “Missed Potential,” I plan to talk about parts of games that don’t live up to their potential. I’ll try to break down why I think they’re incoherent or weak and discuss some possible ways they could be better. I’ll do my best to consider all possible effects of any changes but, as one person and not a team of designers, I’m sure I won’t think of everything. In particular, I’ll focus on things that aren’t in tune with the core themes or systems of the discussed game.

While this particular piece is a little blunt, I don’t plan to tear apart games. As always, I try to focus on bettering the medium that we all enjoy so much. This is about examining weaknesses in order to better the next project as a creator, or to better understand it as a consumer.

Continue reading Missed Potential: Mass Effect 2

A Breath of Fresh Air

The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time fell into my hands after I played it at a friend’s house when I was a child. In a few minutes, I found the Kokiri Sword, something they had been unable to do despite owning and playing the game several times. They handed it to me, since I was “smart enough for it.”

My grandma owned a Nintendo 64, so I played Ocarina of Time at her house. Her and I grew close through it. I remember many late nights, both of us in the CRT’s glow as we worked our way through the temples. I wouldn’t have solved many of the puzzles without her help.

Continue reading A Breath of Fresh Air

Surviving Tselinoyarsk: Degradation in Metal Gear Solid 3

For Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater, Hideo Kojima, series creator and director, decided to step out of the series’ trademark urban infiltration environments in exchange for a Russian jungle that doesn’t exist. Tselinoyarsk, with its swamps, high mountains and dense jungles is quite the departure from Shadow Moses Island and the Big Shell of the two previous games.

Camouflage became the new focus of stealth. Line of sight was still important, but guards had increased detection ranges. They saw farther and heard better. Their hurried hustle became lazy walks. Stealth became a game of lying in the grass and sneaking by as slow as possible instead of trying to dart behind cones of vision displayed on the Soliton Radar of the previous games.

Kojima Productions decided to take full advantage of the game’s jungle setting and added in some extra features to really sell the locale home. Operation: Snake Eater takes place over several days and that means that Naked Snake needs to feed himself. Enter a wildlife and hunting system.

MGS3 isn’t just a stealth game. It’s a survival game, one man versus an army and the unforgiving world around him. Everything in MGS3 has an effect on Naked Snake’s resources. It’s a fight not only to survive the Russian guards but also the player’s ever dwindling resources.

Continue reading Surviving Tselinoyarsk: Degradation in Metal Gear Solid 3

On Cut Content and a Phantom Pain

MAJOR SPOILERS FOR METAL GEAR SOLID V: THE PHANTOM PAIN AND METAL GEAR SOLID 2: SONS OF LIBERTY BELOW.

Let’s talk about review scores, formal analysis and cut content in video games.

Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain is composed of two chapters. The first, “Revenge,” focuses on Skull Face and enacting vengeance for what happened to the original Mother Base in MGSV: Ground Zeroes. The second chapter, “Race,” focus more on the language parasites with an outbreak on Mother Base that leads to Mission 43, “Shining Lights, Even in Death.”

Continue reading On Cut Content and a Phantom Pain

Top 10 Games of 2016

It’s that time of year again. The following list compiles some of my favorite games that I played this year. They are not all 2016 releases. Like last year, here are the rules that I adhered to when organizing the games.

  1. In the case of a non-multiplayer-only game, I must have played its single player experience to completion. This does not require a 100% of all that the game has to offer. Instead, a completion of its main quest, story or campaign will suffice.
  2. In the case of a multiplayer game, I must describe how I played it. Whether cooperative or competitive multiplayer, I will detail whether I played with friends, matchmaking, or online or local multiplayer.
  3. I must have accomplished the above rules in 2016. The games on this list are not all 2016 releases. It is a list of what I played this year.

The 2016 list is missing older classics that made up a significant portion of last year’s list. That’s not because I didn’t play many older games. Far from it. Most of the games that make up this list are contemporary releases or those from recent memory. They were strong enough to distract me from the classics I meant to play and out-charm some of those that I did. 

I also included a couple of the categories from The Steam Awards for fun and I didn’t notice any spoilers below.

Let’s get to it.

Continue reading Top 10 Games of 2016

Possibility and Mass Effect

MASSIVE SPOILERS FOR THE ENTIRE GAME BELOW PLEASE DO NOT SPOIL THIS MAGNIFICENT GAME FOR YOURSELF

Required listening.

Released in late 2007, Mass Effect was another science fiction AAA-blockbuster dropped into an industry saturated by contemporary big-budget shooters like Gears of War, Halo 3 and Half-Life 2: Episode 2. While Mass Effect came from an established studio with what was surely a blockbuster budget, it eschewed industry powerhouse trends in favor of a character-focused story and one of the most pure distillations of role-playing in popular games.

Exploration is at the heart of every good RPG. Humanity is so new to the galaxy, and the player to the Mass Effect universe. In a way, the player learns as Shepard does, about alien races and their cultures, conflicts and forgotten civilizations. There’s a galaxy to explore in the first game with desolate planets to land on with the Mako and a delicious plot to uncover.

Mass Effect’s biggest strength is its faith in its universe and the characters within. Its self-confidence releases the player with little guidance into a game with hours of content to see. Even the planets that compose the game’s main plot are tackled at the player’s discretion or delayed in favor of side quests.

A couple hours into the game, Shepard is given the magic ticket to go anywhere and do anything in the galaxy: Spectre status. As a Spectre, the resources of the galactic government are at his or her disposal. A state-of-the-art ship and a penchant for convincing aliens to join the crew, means there’s always a surprise around the corner.

Continue reading Possibility and Mass Effect